About         Latest News         Programs         Publications         Contribute         Store         Home

 
CRM Header

China Reform Monitor, No. 4, October 30, 1997
American Foreign Policy Council, Washington, D.C.

Administration "Skirts Issue" of Chinese Nuclear Arsenal;
State Department Says Open Dissent in China Has Been Crushed

October 23

Noting the emphasis on concluding a commercial nuclear agreement in time for the summit, the Far East Economic Review says that "On the literally more explosive issue of China's nuclear arsenal, however, the two sides have skirted the issue." The magazine reports China is defensive on issues of missile reductions, is engaged in an ambitious program to upgrade its arsenal, and makes great efforts to hide its strategic missiles underground. Citing Britain's Office of Naval Intelligence, the Review says China's JL-2 ballistic missile, when deployed on its nuclear submarines in the next decade, "would for the first time allow Chinese subs to target parts of the U.S. from areas located near the Chinese coast."

A top Pentagon official responsible for China says the U.S. wants to both deter and engage the People's Liberation Army (PLA). Randall Schriver, senior country director for the PRC, Hong Kong, Taiwan and Mongolia, says U.S. military goals include obtaining a better understanding of the PLA's modernization efforts and reaching operating agreements and confidence building measures such as the Military Maritime safety agreement the administration hopes to announce at the summit. Other agreements such as one covering Defense Department assistance for PRC natural disasters and humanitarian aid are pending but may not be signed.

Saying the Pentagon views the summit as an important event but only in the context of a very long-term engagement strategy, Schriver outlines the Defense Department's policy as being aimed at articulating U.S. intentions and capabilities in order to deter the PLA "in the event of the relationship going in the direction no one wants." Defense Secretary Cohen is expected to press further on transparency issues when he visits Beijing next month.

The Associated Press reports that the Clinton administration "says it is not trying to constrain China's military growth, and it sees no reason to regard the Chinese as a security threat." [Editor's note: Beijing has turned down requests by the Bush and Clinton administrations to de-target the United States.]

Noting that Chinese President Jiang Zemin first made his mark by turning sharply against pro-democracy demonstrators and publications as mayor of Shanghai, the New York Times editorializes, "Deng and other senior leaders then summoned him to Beijing to become Communist Party leader and preside over a relentless crackdown on advocates of greater democracy. He succeeded so thoroughly that the State Department this year concluded that open dissent in China had been crushed."

October 24

The Jiang-Clinton summit is "an elaborate exercise in propaganda . . . intended to serve both to ratify China's post-Tiananmen diplomatic rehabilitation and to solidify Jiang's domestic political status," writes the National Journal's Mike Kelly in the Washington Post. On nuclear matters with Beijing, Kelly says, "a responsible president must not attempt to certify what he cannot know to be so, a responsible Congress must stop, by a veto-proof two-thirds majority, a president who puts the interest of Beijing and Westinghouse ahead of national security. Let's verify before we trust."

--Al Santoli


The American Foreign Policy Council
1521 Sixteenth Street NW, Washington, DC 20036
Email: afpc@afpc.org Phone: 202-462-6055 Fax: 202-462-6045


Copyright © 2000, American Foreign Policy Council.
All Rights Reserved.
Site Designed and developed by pshWizards