RRM Header
Russia Reform Monitor No. 766, April 26, 2000
American Foreign Policy Council, Washington, D.C.

Soviet Coup Plotters Now Better Off Than KGB Critics;
Ukraine Trains Chinese Spies Against Russia

April 18

A former KGB lieutenant colonel warns against the security organs' revenge against "first-wave democrats" who discredited the KGB during glasnost. KGB veteran Konstantin Preobrazhensky, who retired with the same rank as Putin, writes in the Moscow Times, "An open letter [published in Versiya] from former KGB General Oleg Kalugin to Putin -- accusing the new president of placing Russia once again on a totalitarian track -- has struck like a thunderbolt. Kalugin wrote the letter because Putin called him a traitor in a pre-election interview with Kommersant. Putin, a lawyer, called Kalugin a traitor without a trial, ignoring the presumption of innocence. That's the logic of the KGB. As a democrat, appointed by Boris Yeltsin, Putin should have fought against such views; instead, he has used them cynically, leading us to understand that the KGB will be the main organ of power in Russia."

"The KGB generals are out to get [Kalugin] because, at the end of the 1980s, he destroyed the KGB with a single word 'truth.' After Kalugin's exposes were published [during glasnost], the KGB lost society's moral support," Preobrazhensky continues. "Kalugin committed a courageous, self-sacrificing deed. The abolition of the KGB played a positive role in Russian history: It allowed democratic reforms to proceed."

"Dozens of highly placed [KGB] generals lost their posts as a result of Kalugin," according to Preobrazhensky. "Unable to do anything other than 'manage,' they are forced to live on niggardly pensions. In their impotence, they pour heaps of dirt on Kalugin. The offended generals appear on television, and Putin himself has pronounced their baseless accusations of Kalugin's betrayal. Among the generals are those who took part in the August 1991 coup, including Vladimir Kryuchkov and Viktor Grushko. It was Grushko, according to Kalugin, who threatened him at the end of the 1980s, saying that, for his pronouncements against the KGB, Kalugin would be declared insane. But fate decreed otherwise: Grushko was the one accused of being disloyal to the government and sent to prison."

"It turns out that, in today's Russia, it is better to have been a coup organizer in 1991 than a first-wave democrat who put the country on the path toward democracy and freedom," Preobrazhensky continues. Kalugin lives in the U.S. and, though he is not a defector and has not exposed Soviet agents in the U.S., he cannot safely return to Russia. "This is no accident. The hounding of Kalugin acts as a backdrop to the resurrection of the KGB. This is the security services' vengeance for a decade of humiliation by democrats. . .The hounding of General Kalugin has exposed the dangerous process of the KGB's resurgence and the rise of the role of the security services in the political life of Russia."

April 20

The Ukrainian government is training Communist Chinese intelligence to enable Beijing to work more effectively against Moscow. Stratfor.com reports that five Chinese intelligence officers are studying Russian in Lviv, and will take a signals intelligence course at the Kharkiv Radio-Electronic Warfare Institute. Another 18 officers will follow. "If true, such a move demonstrates that Beijing is scrambling to fill a large hole in China's intelligence-gathering operations, and the Ukrainians are willing to help," according to the report. "Such actions also signal that the Sino-Russian relationship is not as firm as Beijing and Moscow would like it to seem.

[Editor's note: For the link, see: http://www.stratfor.com/SERVICES/giu2000/042000.ASP.]

--J. Michael Waller

 

Copyright © 2001, American Foreign Policy Council.
All Rights Reserved.