With the midterm elections in the rearview mirror, the White House is turning to its biggest foreign policy headache: Iran.
It's a fraught subject. Discontent over the Iran war was a major reason for Republicans' drubbing on Election Day, as President Donald Trump himself has conceded. But it's also a problem that demands resolution. Democrats and Republicans alike understand that the status quo – in which a militarized Iranian regime can effectively hold both Persian Gulf security and global energy markets hostage – is untenable.
To change that, the White House is reportedly weighing three main options.
The first is to tighten U.S. economic pressure still further and rely on time to destabilize the Iranian regime. That approach has considerable merit. Operation Economic Outcast, the pressure campaign spearheaded by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, has already taken a heavy toll. According to a recent Treasury Department assessment, the U.S. naval blockade, sanctions and other restrictions have severely damaged Iran's economy and limited its ability to generate revenue.
Washington has also stepped up pressure on Tehran's industrial base and its illicit sanctions-evasion networks.
The cumulative results have been pronounced. The Iranian rial has lost roughly a quarter of its value since August, hitting a staggering low of nearly 2.7 million to the dollar in October. Inflation is soaring, reaching 90% in September. Iran's energy exports, meanwhile, have all but dried up.
By U.S. estimates, the regime hasn't loaded oil onto a tanker since late August, while transit restrictions have grounded Iranian planes and stranded thousands of trucks at the country's borders.
All of which should, presumably, bring Tehran back to the negotiating table. The question is when. Iran's new leaders, many of whom cut their teeth in the grinding (and economically disastrous) eight-year Iran-Iraq war of the 1980s, have proved more resilient than Washington imagined.
Their regime isn't thriving by any stretch. But it is surviving for now, thanks to austerity and the militarization of society. And it's far from clear that the Trump administration has the time or the patience to let its campaign truly bite.
A deal between Washington and Tehran remains out of reach
The second option is a negotiated settlement between Washington and Tehran over the Strait of Hormuz (and, hopefully, Iran's nuclear program as well). On balance, this still seems to be Trump's preferred option to resolve the impasse, although the president has cooled on the option in recent days and taken Vice President JD Vance off the case.
Here, however, the devil is in the details. It's not clear that the Iranian regime, which has weathered U.S. pressure, is prepared to compromise in a meaningful way, either on control of the strait or on its nuclear ambitions. Indeed, Tehran’s current wish list includes an end to the U.S. blockade and the release of frozen assets ahead of any talks with Washington, as well as what amounts to a pledge of future nonaggression from the United States.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio has called some of those demands “outrageous and ridiculous,” pouring cold water on prospects for a near-term breakthrough.
That leaves military action as a means of resetting the strategic equation between Washington and Tehran. Here too, though, American options are constrained.
The public clearly doesn't support protracted operations or another open-ended campaign against Iran. In an October Pew Research Center survey, 65% of Americans disapproved of Trump's handling of the war, while a July Quinnipiac poll found nearly three-quarters of voters oppose sending U.S. ground troops into Iran.
That means any action the White House takes will need to be short, sharp and pegged to clear policy outcomes.
Trump's best bet for Iran is a combined approach.
There is, however, a middle way – one that combines elements of all three. Rather than relying on economic sanctions, diplomatic outreach or military force alone, Washington could pursue a more integrated strategy designed to narrow Tehran's room to maneuver.
Such an approach entails maintaining, and expanding, economic pressure that is already taking a clear toll. The objective would be to deprive Iran's rulers of the resources they need to sustain their military apparatus, subsidize regional terrorist proxies like Yemen's Houthi rebels, and maintain domestic stability through repression.
Military power, meanwhile, should serve as an enforcement mechanism, telegraphing to the regime that any attempt to disrupt regional commerce or target American assets will inevitably trigger a kinetic response. At the same time, persistent diplomacy would offer Tehran a credible off-ramp, provided it proves willing to significantly change its behavior in the region and beyond.
To be sure, there's no guarantee of near-term success. Iran's leadership has proved both willing and able to endure extraordinary economic hardship and military punishment, and more of the same isn't likely to quickly alter that calculus. Still, such an approach would give the White House something it now lacks: a coherent framework that, over time, can translate American military and economic superiority into concrete strategic gains.
Forging such a strategy should be Trump's first priority. Explaining it to a skeptical public and an incoming Democratic Congress needs to be his second.